The American League West Division has been an arms race all offseason. It has seen Ben Sheets go to Oakland, Rich Harden go to Los Angeles, Cliff Lee come to Seattle, and a few returns to the AL West by Joel Pineiro (Angels), Colby Lewis (Rangers) and now reportedly Erik Bedard (Seattle). On paper, the AL West looks like it could very easily be the best pitching division in baseball.
New Angels pitchers Joel Pineiro played for the Mariners from 2000-2006
Let’s start with the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim. They may have lost John Lackey, but their rotation is still very strong. Their five are Jared Weaver (16-8, 3.75 ERA, 211 innings, 174 Ks), Scott Kazmir(10-9, 4.89 ERA, 147+ innings, 117 Ks), Joe Saunders (16-7 4.60 ERA, 186 innings, 101 Ks), Joel Pineiro (15-12, 3.49 ERA, 214 innings, 105 Ks), and Erivin Santana (8-8, 5.03 ERA, 139+ innings, 107 Ks). When all healthy, this will be a frightening starting 5. Santana had a shortened season due to injuries and Kazmir has had previous run-ins with the injury bug as well, but Santana is just one year removed from a 16-win season 200+ inning season and Kazmir owns almost all of the Tampa Bay Rays pitching records.
Much of the A's pitching outcome will depend of if Justin Duchscherer can make a return from last season's surgery
The Oakland Athletics added big right-hander Ben Sheets to their rotation. He missed all of 2009, but hasnt had an ERA over 4.00 since the 2003 season. The rest of their rotation looks to be the following: Brett Anderson (11-11, 4.06 ERA, 175+ innings, 150 Ks), Dallas Braden (8-9, 3.89 ERA, 136+ innings, 81 Ks), Trevor Cahill (10-13, 4.63 ERA, 178+ innings, 90 Ks), and Justin Duchsherer (also missed all of 2009, but had a 2.54 ERA in 22 starts in 08). I’d be shocked if Gio Gonzalez didnt get some time starting as well. Having two pitchers who havent pitched in a full year will allow Gonzalez to rack up the fill in starts. Gonzalez had 109 Ks in 98+ innings but has a high ERA (5.75), so he will most likely not get featured action in the starting rotation. The A’s have a handful of young and talented pitchers who are in need of a veteran influence to guide them and between Duchsherer and Sheets both staying healthy, that could be their guiding light to victory.
Scott Feldman won 17 games in 2009. Can he do it again in 2010?
The Texas Rangers were able to snag a pitcher in Rich Harden that was targeted by many teams, the Mariners included. Yes, this is the same Rich Harden that played for Oakland and consistently tore up Mariners hitters. Harden is a highly effective pitcher but has a dreadful history with injuries, and hasn’t hit the 30-start mark since 2004. Besides Harden the Rangers have Scott Feldman (17-8, 4.08 ERA, 189+ innings, 113 Ks), Colby Lewis (11-9, 2.96 ERA, 176+ innings, 186 Ks in Japan), Derek Holland (8-13, 6.12 ERA, 138+ innings, 107 Ks), and Tommy Hunter (9-6, 4.10 ERA, 112 innings, 64 Ks). Lewis was not impressive in the least bit before playing in Japan for the past two seasons. In Japan, Lewis took back-to-back strikeout titles and is hoping to bring that confidence back tot he states to pitch well in America and the MLB. The Rangers lost Kevin Millwood to the Baltimore Orioles and now more pressure lies on Feldman to repeat his 17-win season success from last season.
The M's are counting on a repeat of King Felix's Cy Young runner-up season from 2009.
The Seattle Mariners made two power deals for their rotation. They traded for Cliff Lee and signed Felix Hernandez to a five-year deal. Hernandez (19-5, 2.49 ERA, 238+ innings, 217 Ks) and Lee (14-13, 3.22 ERA, 231+ innings, 181 Ks) will lead the rotation and be the strongest 1-2 punch in baseball. Behind them are Ryan Rowland-Smith (5-4, 3.74 ERA, 96+ innings, 52 Ks), Ian Snell (7-10, 4.84 ERA, 145 innings, 89 Ks), and starting May or June possibly Erik Bedard (11-7, 3.24 ERA, 164 innings, 162 Ks COMBINED in first two seasons with Seattle), but in the meantime it will be a mixture of our young arms. Most Likely the combination of Jason Vargas, Garret Olsen, and Doug Fister. Those final three being the M’s predominant young starters who have a shot at the mound in 2010. You cannot get more set than Hernandez and Lee to start off the rotation. But beyond those two the questions begin to arise. Rowland-Smith will be entering his first year as a set starter, Snell pitched well in Seattle when coming over from Pittsburgh, but will he continue that new pitching groove or will his old Pittsburgh pitching find its way to Seattle? Bedard, oh Bedard… If he can come back in May or June and stay back, he will pitch great. The reported contract has some say up to an additional 4 or 5 million extra in performance incentives and if Bedard can figure out that good pitching now equals more money next year, he will be back to his pitching ability from Baltimore when people were mentioning his name in the Cy Young race.
The American League West is going to be an exciting division, and I might say the most exciting. Don’t count out the little 4-team division early, there are a lot of talent pitchers packed in and most are just waiting for their time to shine. I anticipate a 1-game playoff in October being the deciding factor on who gets to the playoff spot.